apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Good Question: Norton vs. McAfee?

2007-11-15norton.jpg

Dear readers, we need your advice on this one--a fellow reader wrote to us asking: For all the PC users out there - which is better; Norton AntiVirus or McAfee? Norton is less expensive and I've not had any problems with it in the past. McAfee came with the new laptop and is about to expire. So which is best?
 
 

We have heard that there are some great free options out there, and that Norton and McAfee aren't the best but that the free options are as good if not better...this message board post (near the bottom) sums it up for us.

So, readers, what do you think?

- Image by KrAzY KorY.

Related Links:

  • 3M Security Filters

  • Computer Security Ring

  • Maxtor Sentry Waterproof and Fireproof Hard Drive

  • Tags

    safety & security, computers

    Related Links

    Share

    Comments (21)

    The time of paying for these type of programs is over. I think AVG is the best - I've had it installed on two machines for three years, and have had a total of 0 problems.

    As for a firewall, I suggest ZoneAlarm.

    posted by sgt_easton on November 15th 2007 at 4:37am
    view sgt_easton's profile

    I recommend avast anti-virus. The home license is free and they offer solid protection without many of the headaches caused by Mcafee and Norton.

    posted by foglite on November 15th 2007 at 4:46am
    view foglite's profile

    I've used ZoneAlarm, which works well, and something called Panda AntiVirus.

    And don't forget AdAware... that's a great program too.

    All free, by the way.

    posted by shani-o on November 15th 2007 at 4:54am
    view shani-o's profile

    Back when I was a Windows user, I used Avast. It was free for home users and relatively inexpensive for business use.

    posted by nikkiana on November 15th 2007 at 5:31am
    view nikkiana's profile

    Third for Avast. It's free. No bloat and auto update. What more can you ask.

    posted by Jabber on November 15th 2007 at 5:44am
    view Jabber's profile

    I'm fond of AVG personally, but the important thing is not Norton or McAfee, both of which are poisonous at best.

    posted by moiety on November 15th 2007 at 5:45am
    view moiety's profile

    The best is to learn how not to get a virus and use nothing!

    posted by DaveD on November 15th 2007 at 7:28am
    view DaveD's profile

    AVG or Kaspersky have served relatives well.

    And yeah, I'm going to go there... get a Mac!

    posted by yakimushi on November 15th 2007 at 7:53am
    view yakimushi's profile

    Norton or McAfee?

    I have 2 pc laptops that I use every day. One came with Norton and one came with McAfee. I find them both equally effective and equally annoying. The one with Norton seems to take for bloody ever to bootup. And I do disk cleanups and defrag at least once a day.

    Windwolf

    posted by Windwolf on November 15th 2007 at 8:02am
    view Windwolf's profile

    Windolf, I ditched Norton off of my Dad's machine a month ago. Shaved a minute and a half off the boot up time.

    posted by sgt_easton on November 15th 2007 at 8:21am
    view sgt_easton's profile

    I was the one who posted this question. I'm so happy to find out from all of you that I don't have to pay for a virus protection program. I didn't know I could get them free. I just installed Avast and AdAware (I had that on my old computer). I'll let McAfee expire and hope all of you are right and that I don't get any viruses. Thank you so much for this valuable information.

    posted by anne on November 15th 2007 at 9:33am
    view anne's profile

    I used to have McAfee but discovered it was the reason my computer was running so slowly. When I tried to uninstall it, I developed all sorts of operating system errors and ended up just reinstalling the OS. Now I use nothing (as DaveD suggests) and just run a scan from one of teh free programs online once a week just in case.

    posted by The Green Cat on November 15th 2007 at 10:17am
    view The Green Cat's profile

    Anne,
    I would uninstall McAfee first (and hope that it doesn't trash your computer like it did for Green Cat) before installing Avast. There might be some conflicts with two antivirus programs on your computer.

    posted by Jabber on November 15th 2007 at 10:33am
    view Jabber's profile

    Anne,
    Jabber is right on this...you really, really need to uninstall McAfee before loading up the other programs. Conflicting antivirus programs is not a fun situation.

    posted by sgt_easton on November 15th 2007 at 10:48am
    view sgt_easton's profile

    Well, I've already installed Avast. McAfee's free trial ends on Wed. I don't want the issues that Green Cat had so I'm afraid of uninstalling McAfee since it will end anyway in a few days.

    Any thoughts on this?

    Oh, and I wanted to get a Mac when shopping for a new laptop but they're so expensive. I couldn't afford it.

    posted by anne on November 15th 2007 at 1:18pm
    view anne's profile

    With most ISPs they do give a free security software. Charter, Comcast, AOL and most of the more popular ISP do have packages.

    So, just ask your ISP.

    ...follow the white rabbit...

    posted by ffffffrabbit on November 15th 2007 at 6:19pm
    view ffffffrabbit's profile

    AVG... hands down. avast for a second.

    posted by substance12 on November 15th 2007 at 6:55pm
    view substance12's profile

    What happens when you have conflicting anti-virus programs? I forget which one is active now (I'm at work at the moment) but I don't think I uninstalled the old one before installing the new. I wonder if this might be causing my infuriating, mysterious problem - my computer runs PAAAAAAAAAAAAINFULLY slow online. Dell swears the wireless card is fine, Qwest swears the connection is fine, and my roommate's computer (which is inferior in every other way) runs at normal speeds online. Could it be software related?

    posted by mjoe on November 16th 2007 at 9:15am
    view mjoe's profile

    Chiming in to get on the AVG bandwagon.

    posted by Mat on November 16th 2007 at 12:42pm
    view Mat's profile

    If I had to pick one of these two, I'd go with Norton over McAfee.

    However, I would rather use AVG. I used Norton for quite some time, but my current employer uses AVG, and I've grown to like it better.

    Also, be sure to use two important tools: AdAware and Spybod: Search and Destroy. No PC should be without these!

    posted by leonad on November 20th 2007 at 6:57am
    view leonad's profile

    **That should have been "Spybot: Search and Destroy".

    posted by leonad on November 20th 2007 at 6:57am
    view leonad's profile