apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Do You Trust Your GPS Navigator?

100108_tf_gps.jpgWe've got some weird news: For the second time, a man in Bedford Hills, New York has trusted his GPS so much that he followed directions onto a set of train tracks last night. He made it out, but the train slammed into his empty car, causing no injuries but an almost two-hour delay for passengers. Earlier this year, a different man followed the same directions onto the same track. Being overly trusting of Satellite Navigation is apparently popular enough that some narrow roads in England have signs posted warning wide-vehicle drivers not to follow directions to turn there. GPS navigators are gaining insane popularity and lots of people are buying them for the plethora of convenient features they provide drivers, but like any technology it's not without it's problems. Let's get a discussion going... Do you trust your GPS Navigator?

 
 

We've been known to get lost because we're unknowingly traveling to City Street SE, as our navigator pointed us to, instead of City Street SW. We also once traveled an hour out of our way because our navigator didn't pick up on an access road that it should have.

We want to know: What's the worst pickle your navigator has gotten you into?

Tags

travel, satellite, GPS, technology, directions, driving, fail, lost, navigator, trust

Related Links

Share

Comments (11)

So the GPS told the guy to cross the tracks, and instead of yielding to an oncoming train, he just decided to cross at the exact time the GPS suggested it? I suppose if the GPS said to cross an intersection, the guy would ignore the stop light as well?

This isn't the GPS' fault. The assumption, for anyone with common sense, is that you follow the rules of the road WHILE you're following the directions the unit gives you. It's no different than having a passenger tell you how to get somewhere - you still stop for trains!

The worst thing my GPS ever did was get me lost on my first day at a new job, but that's because the city I work in has many streets with the same name, so it's very easy to get messed up.

posted by confusednazgul on October 1st 2008 at 10:03am
view confusednazgul's profile

Since the first time I used one and it kept saying "WARNING ROAD ENDS" the entire route to my sister's house (which I had traveled many times), I have never bothered with a GPS.

posted by lizaboo on October 1st 2008 at 10:37am
view lizaboo's profile

My GPS is always telling me to "make a U-turn" when it doesn't like the direction I am going. U-turns are not only dangerous but are also illegal here...

posted by Aimi on October 1st 2008 at 10:45am
view Aimi's profile

@ confusednazgul:

I'm not debating that the driver in question isn't a dummy, but what happened was that he DROVE ONTO train tracks when his GPS told him it was a road.

He was basically driving in a narrow space going head-on with a train.

posted by tarynevelyn on October 1st 2008 at 10:52am
view tarynevelyn's profile

I thought that maybe people would use common sense to pull over to the side of the road when looking at these things...

posted by ekoshyun on October 1st 2008 at 10:52am
view ekoshyun's profile

sort of different, but I once borrowed a friend's gps to get to the airport, and after 20 minutes of awkward backroads and an estimated 5.5 hours until arrival (i live 15 miles away), I realized it was set to "pedestrian mode". I felt like an idiot for putting so much trust in this silly little machine and abandoning my common sense. sorry to sound judgmental, but these folks should feel like idiots too.

posted by amt230 on October 1st 2008 at 11:04am
view amt230's profile

This reminds me of "The Office" when Michael Scott is directed to "turn left(or right, I can't remember)," so instead of turning at the intersection 30 in front of him, he turns left immediately and drives down a boat launch into a lake. haha, still makes me laugh

posted by slipperymarshmallow on October 1st 2008 at 1:33pm
view slipperymarshmallow's profile

*30 feet

posted by slipperymarshmallow on October 1st 2008 at 1:34pm
view slipperymarshmallow's profile

slipperymarshmallow, I love that episode! :)

I use the GPS nav on my blackberry, but I don't really follow it EXACTLY.
It was really helpful when I went on a roadtrip from LA to Napa Valley to SF to Monterey back down the PCH to LA. But when I'm using it in semi-familiar areas, I just use it for assistance, not necessarily as a guide. Especially since it's SO slow and I end up missing have of the turn it wants me to make. And there's never really any point in making a u-turn, I don't even know why they have that as an option... especially when it always tells me to make a u-turn at a light where not only are you not allowed to make a u-turn, but it's also pretty friggin impossible.

Ugh. Technology is dumb sometimes.

posted by sparkle on October 1st 2008 at 3:49pm
view sparkle's profile

I use my GPS...but I don't trust it. It's useful at times, but I never just blindly follow the directions.

posted by wunami on October 2nd 2008 at 3:06pm
view wunami's profile

We have sat nav, my boyfriend got it when he moved here (I'm a local), he loves it and I am constantly at odds with it. I literally argue with it out loud in the car. It's been useful when I need to know how to get to somewhere I've never been before, but most of the time I know where we're going better than it does. I esecially hate the U-turn directions it gives. Fortunately, our model sounds less annoyed and ready to kill you than my parents'. Theirs tried to get them to turn around for twenty miles and go back to the interstate on their last road trip.

posted by silentluciditi on October 3rd 2008 at 6:58am
view silentluciditi's profile